48 Theses
How we can live together better
1
Every person is different and special. This must be appreciated and protected.
- About a new image of your own body: https://www.3sat.de/wissen/wissenschaftsdoku/211202-sendung-wido-104.html
- Initiative “For a church without fear”: https://outinchurch.de/
2
From the knowledge of one's own uniqueness, each person develops the ability to recognize others in their uniqueness and to show them respect and appreciation.
- The sociologist Andreas Reckwitz on the search for uniqueness: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L7wuD63gANw
3
Every human being is a seeker. He is free to explore and investigate the world in order to expand and overcome the limits of previous knowledge, provided that others do not feel restricted in their rights as a result.
- Code of Academic Freedom of the University of Hamburg: https://www.uni-hamburg.de/uhh/profil/leitbild/kodex-wissenschaftsfreiheit.html?s=09
4
Every person asks himself questions about the origin of life and the mystery of death. Any answers he chooses to these questions are to be considered equal to the answers of other people. Insofar as he finds them in his faith, these are to be respected to the same extent as the answers of all other faiths.
- About the foundation of the House of One: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2021/feb/21/christians-muslims-and-jews-to-share-faith-centre-in-berlin?CMP=Share_AndroidApp_Other
5
Every person is sensually touched and addressed by other people, natural occurrences, things and artistic forms of expression. With these forms of resonance he experiences himself and the world again and again. By allowing himself to be seduced, seized, but also unsettled by the complexity of life and the diversity of the world, he distinguishes himself as a human being.
- The sociologist Hartmut Rosa on resonance experiences: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MPUW5GbnJcE&feature=youtu.be
- Journalist and author Pico Iyer on the beauty of the unknown: https://www.ted.com/talks/pico_iyer_the_beauty_of_what_we_ll_never_know?utm_source=tedcomshare&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=tedspread
6
Every human being is part of nature. He can only preserve and develop his species if he lives in harmony with nature and does not place himself above it. Every single human being is responsible for this. In order to preserve the diversity of animals and plants, at least one third of the earth's surface should be placed under nature protection.
- The historian and philosopher Philipp Blom on the relationship between man and nature: https://youtu.be/VhRbFA53He8
- Biologist and political scientist Sebastian Unger on protecting the oceans: https://taz.de/Schutz-der-Meere/!5737124/
- Dutch biologist Leen Gorisson on natural intelligence: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MDJ6XrwlfH8
7
Every human being pays attention to the careful and sustainable use of the world's natural resources and uses his reason to preserve them. This gives rise to an obligation for companies to avoid any extensive consumption of resources and to compensate for this either by cultivating renewable raw materials or by investing in alternative, non-fossil energy sources.
- The American legal scholar Jedediah Purdy on the importance of the common good: https://srv.deutschlandradio.de/dlf-audiothek-audio-teilen.3265.de.html?mdm:audio_id=893079
- Political economist Maja Göpel on the relationship between economy and ecology: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hNRU3H5wH1k&feature=youtu.be
8
Everyone has the right to the preservation of clean air and water, as well as protection from harmful environmental influences, radiation hazardous to health and the consequences of global warming. He or she shall work to ensure that climate protection goals are implemented globally and shall personally contribute to wasting less food and reducing traffic and waste.
- The lawyer and author Ferdinand von Schirach on new fundamental rights in Europe: https://you.wemove.eu/campaigns/fur-neue-grundrechte-in-europa
9
Every human being is first and foremost a social being. He needs the integration into a community in which he can live freely and at the same time in responsibility. In the community he develops the ability to shape the world according to his needs and thereby for the benefit of all. As an individual, he voluntarily supports the productive and creative work of others according to his possibilities.
- British economist Noreena Hertz on the topic of loneliness and community: https://www.ardmediathek.de/video/ttt-titel-thesen-temperamente/das-zeitalter-der-einsamkeit-von-noreena-hertz/das-erste/
- The philosopher Omri Boehm and the orientalist Navid Kermani on the topic “Who is we? And who is not?": https://www.rbb-online.de/rbbkultur/radio/programm/schema/sendungen/der_zweite_gedanke/archiv/20230202_1900.html
10
From birth, every human being is confronted with the experience of fear, which makes him vulnerable and in need of protection. In the course of his life he learns to protect himself and also to offer protection to others. Part of protection is actively building and maintaining trust with others.
11
Every person should know that his own future is also in the hands of others. In the course of our lives we learn to set limits to our own narcissism, to open ourselves to others and to treat them with compassion and respect. A prerequisite for living together better and more peacefully is the ability to forgive each other.
- Journalist and author Sven Stillich on the subject of forgiveness: https://www.zeit.de/wissen/gesundheit/2021-03/psychologie-vergebung-schuldgefuehle-liebe-freundschaft-konflikt/komplettansicht
12
13
14
Every person seeks protection and security in the environment that is familiar to him. This gives rise to an inner image of home that accompanies him throughout his life. This image can become the source of unconscious desires for an eternal, unchanging place. But we ourselves and the lake in which we bathe change with time. Therefore, home succeeds only where we feel secure with each other and can develop freely.
15
For every human being the foreign is a challenging chance to move out of the familiar environment. However, the foreign is also associated with threat and fear, which in turn promotes the longing for home and tradition. Human life oscillates between these two spaces of experience. Despite all the uncertainties and unpredictability that come with it, he should shape his life with courage, confidence and reason.
- French sociologist Edgar Morin on the topic of “Our common home”: https://en.unesco.org/courier/news-views-online/edgar-morin-unesco-courier
16
Every person possesses different identities through his ethnic and social origin, his religion, his profession, his political views and his personal and social inclinations. He decides for himself what importance he gives to them. It is not acceptable that others define his identity one-dimensionally, because every human being is a complex and relational social being.
- About identity and otherness: https://www.zeit.de/video/2019-03/6009938444001/alltagsrassismus-wenn-die-frage-woher-kommst-du-zur-belastung-wird
- The Nigerian writer Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie on identity: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o_hsWRVR8_M
- The American actress America Ferrara on identity: https://www.linkedin.com/posts/ted-conferences_my-identity-is-not-my-obstacle-my-identity-activity-6969311577032245248-v_J2?utm_source=share&utm_medium=member_android
17
Every person is required to refrain from all forms of physical or mental violence, especially discrimination and exclusion of others. Each person is also required to moderate language as an instrument of hatred and discord at all times and not to attack or belittle others.
- Publicist Kübra Gümüşay on hate and organized love: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZXgp6E53TIE&feature=youtu.be
18
19
20
21
22
Every person who is entitled to vote shall be given the opportunity to participate in fundamental social decisions in his or her country, particularly in the areas of energy, the environment, education, transportation and infrastructure, within the framework of citizens' votes. These citizen votes are accompanied by a comprehensive discussion process in decentralized and centralized citizen forums. All the information needed to form an opinion is prepared by the media and educational institutions and is available for use at any time.
- On the subject of citizens' votes: https://www.openpetition.de/abstimmung21?op_rf=nl
- How Ireland transformed democracy: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dKSgPtnN0s0
23
Everyone bears responsibility for the cohesion of society in his or her country. In order to shape a vibrant community, he or she is called upon to become involved in institutions such as political parties, associations, schools, universities, trade unions, clubs or religious communities. Those who take responsibility for others or show civil courage receive special appreciation and respect.
- The philosopher and politician Robert Habeck on the topic of responsibility: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gDi5ZB_9yJw&feature=youtu.be
- French writer and journalist Evelyne Pieiller on social responsibility: https://monde-diplomatique.de/!5732044
- The German writer and lawyer Bernhard Schlink on the subject of social responsibility: https://www.zeit.de/2019/08/moral-verantwortung-menschen-pflicht-verhalten
24
Everyone bears responsibility for coming to terms with historical crimes committed in his or her country. He shall contribute to the clarification of the circumstances and causes of these crimes and shall advocate that the perpetrators be held accountable. The victims shall be commemorated in an appropriate manner. Social or economic disadvantages for the affected population groups shall be compensated by national reparation funds.
- The American historian Michael Rothberg on the culture of remembrance: https://www.zeit.de/kultur/2021-03/michael-rothberg-multidirektionale-erinnerung-buch-holocaust-rassismus-kolonialismus/seite-3
- The historian Rebekka Habermas on the recognition of the genocide of the Herero and Nama: https://srv.deutschlandradio.de/dlf-audiothek-audio-teilen.3265.de.html?mdm:audio_id=929298
- The historian Norbert Frei on the debate about post-colonial remembrance culture: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1X8AwENQOcY
25
Any person forced to leave his country because of economic hardship or war shall enjoy the humanitarian protection of the State to which he has fled. With the explicit support of the world community, it is primarily the neighboring countries of the affected state that organize the reception and care of the refugees. Each country can only assume responsibility for refugees to the extent that internal social and cultural cohesion is not jeopardized.
- The historian Andreas Kossert on the subject of flight: https://srv.deutschlandradio.de/dlf-audiothek-audio-teilen.3265.de.html?mdm:audio_id=934996
- On the debate about flight and migration: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nt9jcGQ71Rw&feature=youtu.be
26
27
Every person who emigrates to another country has the obligation to actively integrate into the host country. The host country creates the conditions for him to learn the new language and familiarize himself with the new customs and traditions. He is provided with assistance in finding socially acceptable employment opportunities and adequate housing. The parliament of the host country regularly decides how many people can immigrate.
- The writer Ferda Ataman on Turkish immigration: https://srv.deutschlandradio.de/dlf-audiothek-audio-teilen.3265.de.html?mdm:audio_id=934779
28
29
Every person protects and preserves the cultural heritage of mankind. His own history and creative work can be understood as part of a culture of humanity. In this way, the individual impulse is carried forward across all social boundaries and the memory of humanity is enriched by members of all social groups.
- The American photographer Brandon Stanton on the subject of “Life Stories”: https://www.humansofnewyork.com/
- The “Faces and Phases” project by South African photographer Zanele Muholi: https://publicdelivery.org/zanele-muholi-faces-phases/
- A platform that connects people through their stories: https://storycorps.org/the-science-behind-one-small-step/
30
31
Every person is free to shape his or her life through rituals that can give it structure and order, meaning and continuity, collective identity and a sense of community. The power of ritual can provide a counterpoint to everyday reality, but it can also provide an opportunity to rethink and possibly change our lives and relationships with others. However, a ritual should never be performed under internal or external coercion and lead to the exclusion or discrimination of others.
- The Korean-German philosopher Byung-Chul Han on rituals: https://www.deutschlandfunk.de/byung-chul-han-vom-verschwinden-der-rituale-eine-topologie.700.de.html?dram:article_id=456171
32
Everyone respects the values of an open society characterized by helping the vulnerable and disadvantaged, defending minority rights, and recognizing cultural diversity as enrichment.
- Open letter from writers, journalists and academics for an open culture of debate: https://harpers.org/a-letter-on-justice-and-open-debate/
33
Each person respects the opinion of the other. The highest priority is given to conversation and dialogue as a means of settling conflicts. Non-violent solutions to conflicts require verbal disarmament and the search for compromise or reconciliation of interests.
- Judith Butler: “The power of non-violence” - Why equality prohibits violence: https://srv.deutschlandradio.de/dlf-audiothek-audio-teilen.3265.de.html?mdm:audio_id=894629
34
35
36
Every person contributes to the common good through his or her work. Work is an essential basis of our coexistence and the central source of value creation. Its quality is based on the differentiated experience with the work process and the respective product. It is therefore of particular importance to appreciate and recognize the value of work. In order to be able to adapt to the changing production conditions, which arise in particular as a result of digitalization, comprehensive further training opportunities are offered in good time.
- The American philosopher Michael Sandel on the dignity of work (OV): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Qewckuxa9hw&feature=youtu.be
- The American sociologist Richard Sennett on the future of work: https://youtu.be/z0lCOcLP1CY
- To the data and digital literacy learning platform of the German Adult Education Association: https://www.stadt-land-datenfluss.de/
- On the topic of digital training for the world of work: https://www.iwkoeln.de/studien/paula-risius-susanne-seyda-david-b-meinhard-studienreihe-des-netzwerk-q-40-zur-sicht-des-berufsbildungspersonals.html
37
Everyone is entitled to a working environment that promotes their motivation and performance and enables cooperation. He or she participates in ensuring that the material and intellectual products produced have a social benefit and a meaningful, sustainable and inspiring character. In order to promote a professional reorientation, to support social commitment, to realize an artistic project or to produce a scientific work, there is the possibility of receiving a basic income that secures one's livelihood for a total of three years.
- Philosopher Lisa Herzog and sociologist Anke Hassel on the future of work: https://www.deutschlandfunkkultur.de/manifest-zur-zukunft-der-arbeit-weniger-markt-mehr.2162.de.html?dram:article_id=478504
- Manifesto for the future of work: https://www.zeit.de/kultur/2020-05/wirtschaften-nach-der-pandemie-demokratie-dekommodifizierung-nachhaltigkeit-manifest/komplettansicht
38
Every person who establishes or operates a business shall ensure that its employees receive a wage that is at least equal to the standard industry wage. The highest income earned in a business should exceed three times the lowest income only in exceptional cases.
- Initiative for fair wages in the food service industry (USA): https://onefairwage.site/
39
40
41
Every person is obliged to use his property in such a way that it serves the common good. He bequeaths one-third of his personal property to a charitable foundation or to the state. If it is working capital and the heirs actively continue to operate the company, it remains untouched.
- The economist Marcel Fratzscher on financing a start-up allowance for young people: https://www.zeit.de/wirtschaft/2021-05/jugend-corona-krise-berufseinstieg-bildung-foerderung-finanzierung-sozialpolitik
- Sociologist Jens Beckert on wealth distribution and inheritance: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UgDFmFoUy0c&feature=youtu.be
- How funding for charity can be effective: https://www.givingwhatwecan.org/
42
43
44
Every person may freely trade in goods that do not harm others. The aim is to ensure that world trade complies with Fairtrade criteria and that human rights are respected in global supply and value chains.
- On the adoption of the Supply Chain Act: https://www.zeit.de/wirtschaft/2021-02/lieferkettengesetz-bundesregierung-deutschland-globalisierung-menschenrechte-umweltschutz-bussgeld
- About sustainable world trade: https://www.zeit.de/2021/09/freihandelsabkommen-schweiz-indonesien-nachhaltigkeit-wirtschaft/komplettansicht
45
Every person who rents or acquires land is obliged to cultivate or manage it in such a way that it serves the common good. Of the profit generated, one-third shall go to a charitable foundation or to the state. Land and housing are under special protection of the state. The aim is for at least one-third of the housing stock to be non-profit property and for low-income earners to spend only one-third of their income on rent.
- Topic: Land use and the common good: “Community Land Trust: The idea of a social land platform”: https://polis-magazin.com/2020/01/community-land-trust-die-idee-einer-sozialen-bodenplattform/
46
Every person who is eligible to vote will be given adequate participation rights through citizen votes that affect long-term investments in the future of his or her country or a community of nations. These citizen votes are accompanied by a comprehensive discussion process in decentralized and centralized citizen forums. The level of investment is based on the potential that a national or supranational economy has to secure jobs and create new ones in the future. Investments must be made in such a way that the debts incurred for this purpose are repaid within a reasonable time frame.
- Economist Mariana Mazzucatu on sustainable public investment: https://www.ted.com/talks/mariana_mazzucato_the_covid_19_crisis_is_a_chance_to_do_capitalism_differently?utm_source=tedcomshare&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=tedspread
47
48
Everyone is entitled to compensation from an International Social Fund for the consequences of the global economy where it has caused them demonstrable disproportionate disadvantage or economic harm. Companies are required to diversify their supply chains and shift only a maximum of one-third of their production abroad in order to have sufficient capacity available at home in global crisis situations.
- Austrian economist Harald Fadinger on globalization and right-wing populism: https://www.zeit.de/2019/16/rechtspopulismus-freihandel-globalisierung-demokratische-institutionen/komplettansicht
- The lawyer and author Ferdinand von Schirach on new fundamental rights in Europe: https://you.wemove.eu/campaigns/fur-neue-grundrechte-in-europa
- The indian-american political scientist Parag Khanna on globalization: https://www.zeit.de/kultur/2022-08/globalization-world-order-history-europe-usa
48 Theses
Here we have set up space so that you can share your thoughts on the subject of “How we can live together better” with us and all other interested people.
5 thoughts on “48 Thesen”
Hut ab. Ein kleinster gemeinsamer Nenner. Ein schätzenswerter Appendix zum Grundgesetz. Ein real-utopischer Entwurf. Wolfgang Abendroth würde ihn sicherlich begrüßen!
Ein sehr interessantes Projekt.
Vielen Dank dafür!
What struck me — besides how grand, wise and human your vision is — is also how European you are compared to the views of Americans. The sense of individual rights here is powerful and only getting more unabashedly anti-societal. Cases in point: wearing a mask, climate change; owning a gun (and opposing even the most reasonable restrictions on guns); Trump’s America First. I don’t know if the US has always been this way, but got disguised through lofty ideals of spreading democracy and so-called equality, but we have become an immensely selfish and uncaring people relative to the rest of the world (and even relative to each other). I don’t think I realized how far the US had traveled until reading your 48. My sense is that you could have a fruitful and meaningful discussion of your principles in Europe; the discussion would end before it even started here.
I would like to live in the world your create . . . .
One substantive question: there are a lot of one-thirds. Is there a basis to that across the different principles in which you use it to allocate shares, versus one half or one quarter. Just curious.
In 1960, the top marginal tax rate in the US was 70%; it is now 35%, with capital gains taxed at 20%. Thus, the rich get richer and is disproportions that are extreme. I think this will become the major source of conflict in the US in the coming years. Oddly, most of Trump’s followers are poor white people at the bottom of the food chain lacking college education or upward mobility. You would think they would be at the front of the revolutionary ranks, but no. They’re the ones willing to throw democracy away on a demigod.
One of the basic ideas of my paper was to strengthen the sense of community. After such a long period of prioritising the me-perspective (nothing against #metoo!) I found it important to draw attention to what we can actually give back to society, if we were lucky enough to be born on the bright side of life. So I thought up a very simple formula: 1/3 for my pleasure, 1/3 for my family and friends, 1/3 for society. This I attached to the cases of inheritance, the making
of profit through business, ownership of property or financial transactions.
In case of inheritance its accepting that all you have achieved, is based on what your social and economic starting position was and sharing a reasonable part in order to help others have better conditions in the future. Therefore I say that you can give it to foundations who do good things with it.
In case of profits (!) you make, it seems reasonable to me that those who contributed to it, should have their fair share and if your property gains value without you contributing it’s also fair to have society get a proportion of it.
The 1/3 idea is to define a cultural and social value by fixing a proportion that is easy to communicate, that has a chance to be generally accepted and that has a symbolic function in terms of “if I gain more, I will share more”. To me it should be easy to teach that in school. Growing wealth then always has a social dimension and it will free you of constantly being scrutinized or morally insulted for your achievements. I’m not an expert in this, but it might even keep income taxes fairly low.
The other 1/3 aspects came gradually, are based on already existing demands by NGOs or UN resolutions and of course they are also symbolic and easy to memorize: the UN demands 1/3 of the world’s territority to be natural reservations in order to protect flora and fauna, the towns of Zürich or Vienna have succesfully dealt with social housing issues by making sure that 1/3 of tenements are in public hand, every reasonable bank will only give you a mortgage, if you can provide 1/3 of the necessary capital. And finally, after the Corona experience leading economists proclaimed that it makes sense not to have more than 1/3 of your production line abroad.
Ich finde es wichtig, dass wir uns immer wieder überlegen, was es eigentlich jeden Tag zu tun gilt, um ein friedliches Zusammenleben zu fördern. Als Schweizer Bürger denke ich an die Zeit des Zweiten Weltkriegs, als viele Flüchtlinge an der Grenze zurückgewiesen wurden. Deshalb scheint mir die These 26 sehr wichtig
“Jeder Mensch, der aus politischen, religiösen, ethnischen oder rassistischen Gründen verfolgt wird, hat das Recht in einem Land seiner Wahl Asyl zu beantragen. Dabei entscheidet das Parlament des Gastlandes regelmäßig darüber, in welchem Umfang Menschen Asyl gewährt werden kann. Asylsuchende und Asylberechtigte genießen das Gast- und Aufenthaltsrecht, solange in ihrer Heimat Menschen verfolgt werden und eine Rückkehr in sichere Lebensumstände nicht möglich ist.”
Hier der Link zu einem Video, das ich vor vielen Jahren zu diesem Thema gemacht habe: https://vimeo.com/manage/videos/50214481